GRE Issue Topic 73

GRE Issue Topic 73

Topic:

The most effective way to understand contemporary culture is to analyze the trends of its youth.

Write a response in which you discuss the extent to which you agree or disagree with the statement and explain your reasoning for the position you take. In developing and supporting your position, you should consider ways in which the statement might or might not hold true and explain how these considerations shape your position.

موثرترین راه برای درک فرهنگ معاصر، تحلیل گرایشات جوانان آن است.

پاسخی بنویسید که در آن درمورد موافقت یا مخالفت با این جمله بحث کنید و استدلال خود را درباره موضع گیری خود توضیح دهید. در توسعه و حمایت از موضع خود، باید روشهایی را در نظر بگیرید که طبق آن، این نظریه ممکن است درست باشد یا نباشد و توضیح دهید که این ملاحظات چگونه موضع شما را شکل می دهند.

موافق

  • فرهنگ مجموعه ای از رسم و رسومات، عقاید، رفتار و منش عموم مردم است و فرهنگ هر جامعه نسبت به مسائل روز دستخوش تغییر می شود. بنابراین، می‌توان با ارزیابی گرایش جوانان تا حدودی مسیر فرهنگی معاصر را درک کرد.
  • معمولاً جوانان توانایی و قدرت بیشتری برای تحمیل کردن عقاید و نظرات خود به نسل قبل دارند. به همین علت، ارزیابی گرایش جوانان بهتر می تواند مشخص کننده فرهنگ‌معاصر باشد.
  • جوانان بخشی از منش و رفتار خود را از پدر و مادرشان یا در حقیقت نسل قبل یاد می‌گیرند و بخش دیگری را از اطرافیان و دوستانشان که با پیشرفت های جدید، هماهنگ و همگام هستند. پس ارزیابی گرایشات جوانان جامعه می‌تواند برای درک فرهنگ معاصر مناسب باشد.

مخالف

  • فرهنگ معاصر هر کشور می تواند تحت تاثیر فاکتورهای متعددی باشد. گرایش جوانان فقط بخشی از فرهنگ معاصر هر کشور را تشکیل می‌دهد و تکیه کردن به آن نمی تواند ارزیابی کاملی از فرهنگ معاصر باشد.
  • گرایشات جوانان به علت طبع متغیری که دارند می‌تواند در اثر عوامل مختلفی مثل تبلیغات، فشن یا مد روز به سرعت تغییر کند. بنابراین، پیگیری گرایش جوانان نمی تواند معیار درستی برای ارزیابی فرهنگ معاصر باشد.
  • بررسی گرایش جوانان می تواند نشان دهد که تبلیغات فرهنگی چه تاثیری روی فرهنگ معاصر دارد اما نمی‌تواند ارزیابی کاملی از فرهنگ معاصر باشد.
  • در کنار گرایش جوانان فاکتورهای مختلف دیگری مثل اینکه بزرگسالان از چه روش هایی برای تامین نیاز جوانان استفاده می‌کنند و خوراک و پوشاک و امنیت آنها را تامین می کنند و همچنین نحوه رفتار والدین و اقشار مختلف جامعه مثل مدارس و دانشگاه‌ها با جوانان باید مورد بررسی قرار گیرد.
  • زمانی می‌توان فرهنگ معاصر را به طور کامل درک کرد که ارزیابی جامعی از رسم و رسومات، عقاید و رفتارهای کل جامعه و نحوه زندگی کردن آنها داشته باشیم. بنابراین، علاوه بر ارزیابی گرایش جوانان باید روش زندگی بزرگسالان و حتی کهنسالان نیز مورد بررسی قرار گیرد.

 

 

Strategies
Restate the Issue:
How can you change the statement without changing its meaning?
In other words:
The least effective way to understand contemporary culture is to ignore the trends of its youth.
Or: The surest way to misunderstand contemporary culture is to ignore the trends of its youth.
Determine what question is being answered by the issue statement.
How can one understand contemporary culture?
Creating a question will help you to think about how you would respond. Your answer to the question can help you develop your response to the statement.
Now think about the parts of the statement that provide evidence that you can affirm or refute.
a) most effective – Most is the superlative form of many; nothing is more effective.
b) understand – This statement assumes that one can understand contemporary culture.
c) analyze – Analysis is the process of breaking something down into its components. What are the components of the trends?
d) youth – What age group specifically? Does the term, youth, extend to those in college?

Opposing statement:
The most effective way to understand contemporary culture is not to analyze the trends of its youth.
Identify the parts of the opposing statement that provide evidence that you can refute or affirm.
a) not – In this case, the implication is that one should ignore the trends of a culture’s youth. Including those trends might give a false impression of the culture.

Alternatives:
Is there another way to look at this issue? Can you qualify the original issue statement in some way?

New viewpoint:
Analyzing the trends of its youth is one component in understanding the contemporary culture.
Identify the parts of the new statement that provide evidence to affirm or refute.
a) one – This implies that there are others.
b) contemporary – The culture of this time.

Sample 1:

The culture of any era is defined by a variety of elements and may be the result of past influences. Analyzing the trends of today's youth is only one of those elements. One also needs to analyze the kinds of work that adults are pursuing or the activities its senior citizens are participating in. To rely solely on analysis of youth trends is short–sighted. The youth of a culture are heavily influenced by the latest, hottest fad. Their greatest need is to fit in, to be cool, and they change their clothes, their hair, and their phones as soon as the newest fashion is featured in print or on television. Their permanence is ephemeral, and their influence may be longer lasting. A big chunk of their time would be spent just keeping up. Anyone attempting to analyze the trends of youth will barely finish before the trends change.

The most widely–exposed youth culture of the last half century is that of the 1960's and 70's. The youth of that era advised others to tune in, turn on, and drop out. Drugs, sex and rock and roll permeated the culture of youth in those decades. Because burning draft cards and bras was so widely publicized, it would be tempting to believe that all youth behaved in that manner. That would be a mistake. Despite the presence of SDS chapters, peace rallies and sit–ins on college campuses across the country, most students quietly went about attending classes, graduating and getting traditional jobs. The counterculture of the 60's and 70's had its greatest influence on later decades. Those days of rebellion and revolution led to increased opportunities for minorities and women. The young people of that era are now nearing retirement and are living lives very different from the senior citizens of previous generations. They have tuned in, but they have not dropped out. They are healthier, better educated, and leading more active lives than their parents or grandparents did.

Analysis of youthful trends reveals what effect advertising had on a culture's young people. To fully understand contemporary culture, one must analyze the hopes, fears, and actions of all the groups that comprise it. A culture's youth is blissfully ignorant of a culture's realities. The struggle of adults to find satisfying work, to pay the bills, to provide security for themselves and their children define the attitudes and behaviors of contemporary culture.

 

Sample 2:

Our culture is our customs, beliefs and attitudes. It is the way of life that the people of a particular country, class or society follow at a particular time. The culture of a society or country keeps changing and new trends and beliefs keep replacing the older ones. It is the young who exhibit their culture most typically. However, it is also true that the older generation also has its ways of following its culture and beliefs and the old should not be ignored. I believe, while the old are moderate in following their culture, which might be different from that of the youth, they are equally a part of the society. Hence, a proper understanding of the contemporary culture of any place can be done only by a comprehensive study of the trends of the youth as well as the way of life of the old.

Since culture keeps on changing, what was seen as a prominent trend in the olden times may not be so today. This means that culture does not remain fixed. However, it is possible that in a society at a particular time more than one culture co-exist. When it comes to understanding the contemporary culture of a society, it is the young who are the most expressive. By nature itself, the young are flamboyant. Therefore, the trends and beliefs they follow are noticed the most. They are the ones to accept the latest changes first of all and make it their trend. What they wear, think, do, and eat reflects the attitude and trends followed in the contemporary society. A superficial study would indicate that the popular culture followed by the youth is the culture of that society.

On the other hand, a proper understanding of the real contemporary culture is done only when it is studied in totality. That means the whole population should be considered and the trends followed by all the members of the society are studied. It may be true that the youth are most expressive and the contemporary culture is generally seen in their behaviours and beliefs, it is also true that the old form a large part of the society. They have their own culture, customs and beliefs. Most of these people prefer to follow their culture without expressing it. They are not flashy about their ways of lives. This is the reason that the culture they follow is not observed as the culture of the society. However, ignoring this section of the society and considering the culture of the youth as the contemporary culture would be shutting our eyes to half of the truth. A proper understanding of the society is done only when the cultures, customs, beliefs and attitudes of all the sections of a society are taken together.

As mentioned earlier, at one point of time there are more than one culture that co-exist. It is easy to read and observe the culture followed by the young as compared to that followed by the old. Although it is the beliefs and trends of the youth that come out when a society is observed for its culture, it only reflects a part of its composite culture. A society is made up of different types of people and thus different cultures are intermingled in it. Therefore, a study of the culture of a society will be complete and justified only when all the people and their trends are studied.


نظرات کاربران

هنوز نظری درج نشده است!